HHairGrowthReviews
Hair Growth & Hair Loss

Viviscal vs Nutrafol: Which Hair Supplement Is Better?

Two of the best-known hair supplements, side by side. Here is how Viviscal and Nutrafol differ on ingredients, research, price and fit, so you can pick the one that matches your hair and your budget.

The Short Answer

Viviscal vs Nutrafol comes down to budget and what you want the formula to do. Viviscal is a lower-cost marine-protein tablet with vitamins and minerals, taken twice a day. Nutrafol is a pricier botanical blend with ashwagandha and saw palmetto, taken as four capsules daily, with separate formulas for different life stages. Both have company-funded clinical studies behind them.

Top Picks: Best Hair Growth Vitamins

  1. Nutrafol Women Hair Growth Supplements, Ages 18-44 (1-Month Bottle)

    Best Overall

    Nutrafol Women Hair Growth Supplements, Ages 18-44 (1-Month Bottle)

    Check Price
  2. Viviscal Hair Growth Supplements for Women (180 Tablets, 90-Day Supply)

    Best Value Branded Formula

    Viviscal Hair Growth Supplements for Women (180 Tablets, 90-Day Supply)

    Check Price
  3. Nutrafol Men Hair Growth Supplements, Ages 18-49 (1-Month Bottle)

    Best for Men

    Nutrafol Men Hair Growth Supplements, Ages 18-49 (1-Month Bottle)

    Check Price
See all 7 picks in our Best Hair Growth Vitamins guide →
HG

Written by HairGrowthReviews Editorial Team

Reviewed by Ernesta Malinauskytė, PhD, Director of Hair Research, TRI Princeton

Updated 2026-11-19 · Independently researched · How we review

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. How we research

The Short Version

  • Viviscal is built around AminoMar, a marine complex of collagen and oyster extract, plus biotin, zinc, iron and vitamin C; it is not suitable for fish or shellfish allergies.
  • Nutrafol is built around a botanical blend that includes ashwagandha, saw palmetto, curcumin and tocotrienols, with separate Women, Women's Balance (45+), Postpartum and Men formulas.
  • Both brands point to company-funded clinical studies of their own formulas, which is more than most hair supplements can offer.
  • Viviscal starts at about $40 a month on its own site; Nutrafol lists $88 for a one-month bottle, or less on subscription.
  • Viviscal's hair supplements are swallowed tablets or capsules, not gummies, and both brands suggest giving them three to six months.

Viviscal vs Nutrafol is one of the most searched match-ups in the hair supplement aisle, and it is easy to see why. Both are household names, both sit on dermatology-office shelves and pharmacy counters, and both promise fuller, healthier-looking hair from a daily supplement. If you are ready to try one, the real question is which one fits you.

The good news is that you are choosing between two of the more carefully studied products in the category. Each brand has run clinical studies on its own finished formula rather than simply pointing to research on individual ingredients. Where they differ is in what is inside the bottle, who each formula is designed for, how many pills you take and what you pay every month.

Below, we walk through what each supplement is, compare their key ingredients side by side, look honestly at the research, and break down price and value. Then we cover which one suits women, men, menopause, postpartum and stress-related shedding, answer whether Viviscal is chewable, explain how long to give each one, and flag the safety points worth knowing, from biotin and lab tests to ashwagandha. If you want the wider field, our guide to the best hair growth vitamins ranks both brands alongside simpler single-nutrient options.

What Viviscal and Nutrafol Are

Both are oral hair supplements sold without a prescription, and neither is a drug. They are designed to support the hair you grow from the inside out, and both are often used alongside treatments such as minoxidil.

Viviscal

Viviscal has been sold since 1992, according to the brand, and is now part of Church & Dwight. Its signature ingredient is AminoMar, a marine complex that Viviscal lists as collagen and oyster extract powder. Around it sits a straightforward nutrient blend: biotin, vitamin C, iron, zinc, niacin and calcium, plus horsetail and millet seed extracts.

The core women's product is the Viviscal Hair Growth Supplement, taken as two tablets a day with food and water. There is also a Men's Hair Growth Supplement built on the same marine collagen complex, and a newer 4D Hair Growth Cycle Supplement, which is a capsule built around a soluble keratin ingredient with biotin, zinc and B vitamins. Viviscal is widely stocked at pharmacies and big-box stores as well as on its own site.

Nutrafol

Nutrafol takes a broader approach. Rather than leaning on one signature protein, it combines standardized botanicals with vitamins and minerals under the name Synergen Complex. The idea is to support several things that can contribute to thinning at once, including stress, inflammation, hormones and nutrition.

Nutrafol sells separate formulas by life stage: Women for ages 18 to 44, Women's Balance for 45 and over, Postpartum for the first year after childbirth, and Men for 18 to 49, with a Men 50+ version as well. Every formula is taken as four capsules a day. Nutrafol sells mostly direct on subscription, and it is also stocked by many dermatology practices.

Key Ingredients Side by Side

The ingredient lists show the clearest difference between the two brands. Viviscal is protein-and-nutrient led, while Nutrafol is botanical led.

Viviscal's women's tablet lists 1,072 mg of its AminoMar marine complex per two-tablet serving, alongside 240 mcg of biotin, 20 mg of iron, 22 mg of zinc and 118 mg of vitamin C, plus niacin, calcium, horsetail extract and millet seed extract. Iron and zinc are worth noticing because low levels of either are well-documented contributors to shedding, so Viviscal's blend can be especially helpful for anyone who runs low.

Viviscal is protein-and-nutrient led, while Nutrafol is botanical led.

Nutrafol's Synergen Complex includes Sensoril ashwagandha, saw palmetto, curcumin and a tocotrienol complex, which are shared across its core formulas, along with other botanicals such as Moldavian dragonhead. Saw palmetto is included for its effect on DHT, the hormone behind pattern hair loss, and ashwagandha is there for stress support. Women's Balance is described by retailers as adding maca and astaxanthin, two ingredients on Nutrafol's Synergen Complex Plus list, for women going through menopause.

Nutrafol has also updated its Women formula. On its own site, the women's 18 to 44 product is now labeled an improved formula made biotin-free with smaller capsules, and coverage of the update describes it dropping marine collagen in favor of plant-based ingredients. Formulas change, so always read the current label of the exact bottle you buy.

ViviscalNutrafol
Signature ingredientAminoMar marine complex (collagen and oyster extract)Synergen Complex botanical blend
Key botanicalsHorsetail and millet seed extractsAshwagandha, saw palmetto, curcumin, tocotrienols
Vitamins and mineralsBiotin, vitamin C, iron, zinc, niacin, calciumVitamins and minerals vary by formula
BiotinYes, 240 mcg in the women's tabletWomen formula now biotin-free; check other labels
Daily dose2 tablets4 capsules
FormulasWomen's, Men's, 4D capsuleWomen, Women's Balance, Postpartum, Men, Men 50+
Allergen noteMarine-derived; contains mollusksSome formulas contain marine collagen
Swipe the table to see more →

What the Clinical Evidence Shows for Each

This is where both brands stand out from the crowd. Most hair supplements rely on research into individual ingredients. Viviscal and Nutrafol have each studied their finished formulas, and both have published company-sponsored, placebo-controlled studies.

Viviscal says its collagen complex has been studied in 10 clinical trials in women and men. These were mostly small trials in women with self-perceived thinning, and they reported improvements in hair counts and shedding compared with placebo. On its product page, Viviscal cites a study in which women saw a 32% increase in terminal hairs and nearly 40% less shedding over three months. Its packaging also highlights a six-month study in which 92% of participants said their hair looked thicker and 97% said it looked glossier, which are participant-reported results.

it simply means the evidence is encouraging rather than definitive

Nutrafol says it has more than 25 clinical studies, including randomized, placebo-controlled trials. For its current products it reports six-month studies in which participants taking Nutrafol Women, Postpartum and Men experienced significant hair growth, with the Women's Balance study showing significant growth compared with placebo. It also reports a nine-month study for Men 50+. Nutrafol's placebo-controlled trials have found more improvement in hair counts and appearance with the supplement than with placebo.

It is worth reading these results with a clear eye. Both companies funded their own studies, the trials are generally small, and independent replication is limited. That does not take away from what they found; it simply means the evidence is encouraging rather than definitive. Neither product is FDA-approved to treat hair loss, and neither is a substitute for minoxidil or finasteride in genetic pattern hair loss, where those treatments have far larger independent research bases.

Price and Value: What Each Costs per Month

Price is often the deciding factor, and here the gap is real. On viviscal.com, the women's Hair Growth Supplement starts at $40 for a 60-tablet, one-month supply, with larger three-month and six-month sizes. Pharmacies and big-box retailers frequently run it on sale, and the 90-day pack typically works out to well under half Nutrafol's monthly cost.

On nutrafol.com, a one-month supply of the Women, Women's Balance or Postpartum formula lists at $88. A monthly subscription brought that down to $66 a month when we checked, and Nutrafol says you can pause or cancel anytime. Nutrafol also runs regular promotions on three-month and six-month subscriptions, so the price you pay depends on how and when you buy.

If budget matters, Viviscal lets you complete a fair trial for much less.

Both brands back their products with a guarantee, with different conditions. Our Viviscal review notes a 90-day money-back guarantee on direct purchases. Nutrafol offers a results-in-six-months-or-your-money-back guarantee, but it requires buying six bottles by subscription within 180 days, taking four capsules daily, using the myNutrafol app and submitting monthly progress photos. Read the current terms before you order either one, and keep your receipts.

Value is more than the sticker price. Because any hair supplement needs three to six months, think in terms of a full trial: roughly $120 to $240 for Viviscal versus several hundred dollars for Nutrafol, depending on discounts. If budget matters, Viviscal lets you complete a fair trial for much less. If you want the broader botanical formula, Nutrafol's subscription pricing makes it more manageable.

ViviscalNutrafol
One-month price (brand site)From $40$88 one-time
SubscriptionAvailable; free shipping on subscriptions$66 a month when we checked; pause or cancel anytime
Pills per day2 tablets4 capsules
Where to buyBrand site, pharmacies, big-box stores, AmazonBrand site, dermatology offices, select retailers
Guarantee90 days on direct purchases6 months, with subscription and photo conditions
Swipe the table to see more →

Viviscal vs Nutrafol for Women (and for Men)

Both brands are especially popular with women, and both make products for men. The best fit depends on your age, your life stage and what you suspect is behind your thinning.

Women 18 to 44

Either is a good choice. Viviscal suits women who want a simple, lower-cost tablet with iron and zinc built in, which is particularly helpful if heavy periods or diet leave you running low. Nutrafol Women suits those who want a broader formula aimed at stress and inflammation, and its updated biotin-free version is handy if you want to avoid biotin.

Menopause and perimenopause

Nutrafol has the edge here because it makes a dedicated formula. Women's Balance is designed for women 45 and over, and Nutrafol reports a six-month placebo-controlled study in this group. Viviscal does not make a menopause-specific version, though its women's tablet is suitable for adult women of any age. Hormonal shifts in midlife can unmask female pattern hair loss, so this is also a great time to talk to a dermatologist about adding minoxidil.

Postpartum

Postpartum shedding is very common and usually settles on its own within months. Viviscal says its tablets are not intended for pregnant or nursing women. Nutrafol makes a Postpartum formula for the first year after childbirth, which it says was developed with an OB-GYN using breastfeeding-friendly ingredients and recommends while breastfeeding. Check with your doctor or midwife before starting any supplement while you are nursing.

Stress-related shedding

If stress is a big part of your story, Nutrafol's inclusion of ashwagandha, an adaptogen traditionally used for stress, makes it the more targeted pick. Stress-related shedding, known as telogen effluvium, often improves once the trigger eases, so pairing a supplement with sleep, nutrition and stress management gives you the best chance.

Men

Nutrafol Men leans on saw palmetto, the botanical with the most supplement-aisle evidence for slowing male pattern hair loss, and Nutrafol has published company-sponsored data in men. Viviscal Men's uses the same marine collagen complex as the women's line at a lower monthly price than Nutrafol. For men, either works best as an add-on to finasteride or minoxidil, which do the heavy lifting against DHT-driven loss.

Nutrafol Women Hair Growth Supplements, Ages 18-44 (1-Month Bottle)

Our #1 pick for hair growth vitamins

Nutrafol Women Hair Growth Supplements, Ages 18-44 (1-Month Bottle)

The most credible branded hair supplement for women, with research behind the formula and a broad, thoughtful approach.

Check Price

Is Viviscal Chewable? Viviscal Gummies vs Tablets

Viviscal's hair supplements are designed to be swallowed. The women's and men's Hair Growth Supplements are tablets taken twice a day with food and water, and the 4D Hair Growth Cycle Supplement is a capsule. Retail listings describe the women's tablet as easy to swallow, and it carries a light flavor, but it is not meant to be chewed.

When we checked viviscal.com, the brand did not list a gummy or chewable version of its hair supplement. If you come across a listing for Viviscal gummies elsewhere, check that it is sold by the brand or an authorized retailer and read the supplement facts panel carefully, since a gummy would have a different formula from the tablets that were studied.

Viviscal's hair supplements are designed to be swallowed.

Nutrafol is also a swallowed capsule, and you take four a day. If you find pills hard to manage, two simple tips help: take the capsules or tablets one at a time with a full glass of water during a meal, and spread them across breakfast and dinner. If a chewable is a must, a biotin-and-keratin gummy such as OLLY Heavenly Hair is a tasty, approachable option, though it is a general nutritional top-up rather than a formula with its own clinical trials.

How Long to Try Viviscal or Nutrafol

Hair grows roughly a centimeter a month, and the strands you see today started growing months ago. That is why both brands ask for patience. Viviscal recommends at least three to six months of daily use, and Nutrafol says visible thickening and strengthening appear in three to six months.

A practical plan is to commit to three months as your first checkpoint and six months for a full verdict. Many people notice less shedding first, in the shower drain or on the hairbrush, before hair starts to look fuller. Branded trials typically measure results over three to six months for exactly this reason.

commit to three months as your first checkpoint and six months for a full verdict

To read your results fairly, take photos of your part, hairline and crown in the same lighting before you start and then every month or two. Take the full daily dose every day, since missed doses make results hard to judge. If you see sudden, patchy or rapidly worsening hair loss at any point, see a dermatologist rather than waiting it out.

Safety: Biotin, Allergies, Pregnancy and Ashwagandha

Both supplements are generally well tolerated, and a few simple checks will keep you safe and confident.

Biotin and lab tests

Many laboratory tests use biotin-based chemistry, and high blood levels of biotin from supplements can interfere with them. The FDA has warned that biotin can cause falsely low results on some troponin tests, which are used to diagnose heart attacks, and it can distort thyroid tests in ways that mimic disease. Viviscal's women's tablet contains biotin, and its 4D capsule contains a much larger 3,000 mcg dose. Nutrafol's Women formula is now biotin-free, but check the label of any other formula. Tell your doctor and the lab about every product you take that contains biotin, and ask whether to pause it before a blood draw.

Fish and shellfish allergies

Viviscal's marine complex is made from collagen and oyster extract, and its men's label states that it contains mollusks, so it is not suitable for anyone with a fish or shellfish allergy, or for vegans and vegetarians. Some Nutrafol formulas also contain marine collagen, so check the allergen panel of the exact formula you buy.

Pregnancy and breastfeeding

Viviscal says its supplements are not intended for pregnant or nursing women or anyone under 18. Nutrafol recommends skipping its supplements while pregnant or trying to conceive, and offers its Postpartum formula for breastfeeding. Saw palmetto has hormonal activity and is not advised during pregnancy, and ashwagandha is also generally avoided.

Ashwagandha cautions

Ashwagandha, a key Nutrafol ingredient, is popular and widely used, but it is not for everyone. Talk to your doctor first if you have a thyroid condition or take thyroid medication, have an autoimmune condition, take sedatives, or take medicine for blood sugar or blood pressure. Rare cases of liver problems have been reported with ashwagandha supplements, so stop and seek medical advice if you notice yellowing skin or eyes, dark urine or unusual fatigue.

Iron and stacking

Viviscal's women's tablet provides 20 mg of iron. If you already take an iron supplement or a multivitamin, add up your totals, and keep all iron-containing products away from children. Avoid stacking several hair products, since excess vitamin A and selenium can themselves contribute to hair loss.

Which Is Better, Viviscal or Nutrafol? Our Verdict by Situation

There is no single winner, because each one is the better buy for a different person. Here is how we would choose.

Pick Viviscal if you want a well-studied branded supplement at a friendlier price, you like the idea of iron and zinc in the formula, and you have no fish or shellfish allergy. It is easy to find, takes two tablets a day, and lets you complete a full six-month trial without a big outlay.

There is no single winner, because each one is the better buy for a different person.

Pick Nutrafol if you want a broader botanical formula aimed at stress, hormones and inflammation, if you are in menopause or postpartum and want a formula designed for that stage, or if you prefer the biotin-free Women formula. It costs more, but subscription pricing softens that, and it is the more targeted choice for life-stage changes.

Whichever you choose, start with a simple blood panel, including ferritin, vitamin D and thyroid tests, so you know whether a deficiency is part of the picture. And remember that both supplements shine as supporting players: paired with minoxidil, and finasteride for men, they round out a routine that gives your hair the best possible chance.

Better pickWhy
Tight budgetViviscalStarts around $40 a month
Low iron or zincViviscalIncludes 20 mg iron and 22 mg zinc
Menopause (45+)NutrafolDedicated Women's Balance formula
Postpartum and breastfeedingNutrafolDedicated Postpartum formula
Stress-related sheddingNutrafolContains ashwagandha
Men with pattern lossNutrafolSaw palmetto, alongside finasteride or minoxidil
Fish or shellfish allergyNutrafol (check label)Viviscal is marine-derived
Avoiding biotinNutrafol WomenNow labeled biotin-free
Swipe the table to see more →

Frequently Asked Questions

Is Viviscal or Nutrafol better?

Neither is better for everyone. Viviscal is the better value, with a marine protein complex plus iron and zinc for about $40 a month. Nutrafol is the broader botanical formula, with dedicated versions for menopause, postpartum and men, at a higher price. Both have company-funded clinical studies behind them.

Is Viviscal chewable?

No. Viviscal's hair supplements are tablets, plus a newer capsule, and they are meant to be swallowed with food and water. When we checked viviscal.com, the brand did not list a gummy version. If you need a chewable, a dedicated hair gummy such as OLLY Heavenly Hair is an easy alternative.

Which is better for women, Viviscal or Nutrafol?

For women 18 to 44, both are good choices: Viviscal for value and built-in iron and zinc, Nutrafol Women for a botanical formula that is now biotin-free. For women 45 and over, Nutrafol Women's Balance is designed specifically for menopause. After childbirth, Nutrafol Postpartum is the one designed for that stage.

Can you take Viviscal and Nutrafol together?

It is best to choose one. Taking two hair supplements together can push biotin, vitamins and minerals higher than you need, and excess vitamin A or selenium can even contribute to hair loss. Pick the formula that fits you best and give it three to six months.

Do Viviscal and Nutrafol contain biotin?

Viviscal's women's tablet contains 240 mcg of biotin, and its 4D capsule contains 3,000 mcg. Nutrafol's Women formula is now labeled biotin-free; check the label of other Nutrafol formulas. If you take any biotin, tell your doctor and the lab before blood tests, since it can affect thyroid and troponin results.

How long does it take for Viviscal or Nutrafol to work?

Both brands suggest three to six months of daily use. Many people notice less shedding first and fuller-looking hair later. Use three months as a first checkpoint and six months for a full verdict, and take monthly photos in the same lighting to track progress.

Is Nutrafol worth the extra cost over Viviscal?

It can be, if you want its broader botanical approach or a formula designed for menopause, postpartum or stress. If your main goal is a studied branded supplement at a lower monthly cost, Viviscal delivers that well. Subscription pricing brings Nutrafol's cost down noticeably.

Can men take Viviscal or Nutrafol?

Yes. Both brands make men's formulas. Nutrafol Men is built around saw palmetto, which targets DHT, and Viviscal Men's uses the marine collagen complex at a lower monthly price than Nutrafol. Men with pattern hair loss get the most from either as an add-on to finasteride or minoxidil.

The Bottom Line

Viviscal and Nutrafol are two of the best-studied hair supplements you can buy, and the right one depends on your budget and life stage. Choose Viviscal for a lower-cost marine-protein tablet with iron and zinc, as long as you have no fish or shellfish allergy. Choose Nutrafol for a broader botanical formula, especially for menopause, postpartum or stress-related shedding. Give either one three to six months, tell your doctor about biotin before blood tests, and pair it with proven treatments for the fullest results.