HHairGrowthReviews
Hair Growth & Hair Loss

Pumpkin Seed Oil vs Saw Palmetto: Which Is Better for Hair Loss?

Two of the most popular natural DHT-pathway supplements, side by side. Here is how pumpkin seed oil and saw palmetto compare on research, dose and safety, which one suits you, and how to take them together.

The Short Answer

Pumpkin seed oil vs saw palmetto is a close call, and both are gentle, plant-based options for early pattern hair loss. Pumpkin seed oil has one well-designed placebo-controlled trial in men; saw palmetto has several small trials, including a head-to-head comparison with finasteride. Both are thought to mildly inhibit 5-alpha reductase, and many people take them together in one softgel.

Top Picks: Best Pumpkin Seed Oil for Hair Loss

  1. NOW Supplements Pumpkin Seed Oil 1000 mg, Cold Pressed (200 Softgels)

    Best Overall

    NOW Supplements Pumpkin Seed Oil 1000 mg, Cold Pressed (200 Softgels)

    Check Price
  2. Nature's Way Pumpkin Seed Oil, Cold Pressed (60 Softgels)

    Best Starter Bottle

    Nature's Way Pumpkin Seed Oil, Cold Pressed (60 Softgels)

    Check Price
  3. PURA D'OR Organic Pumpkin Seed Oil, Pure Cold-Pressed (4 oz)

    Best Topical Oil

    PURA D'OR Organic Pumpkin Seed Oil, Pure Cold-Pressed (4 oz)

    Check Price
See all 6 picks in our Best Pumpkin Seed Oil for Hair Loss guide →
HG

Written by HairGrowthReviews Editorial Team

Reviewed by Ernesta Malinauskytė, PhD, Director of Hair Research, TRI Princeton

Updated 2026-11-19 · Independently researched · How we review

We may earn a commission when you buy through our links, at no cost to you. As an Amazon Associate we earn from qualifying purchases. How we research

The Short Version

  • Both supplements are thought to gently inhibit 5-alpha reductase, the enzyme that turns testosterone into DHT, the hormone behind pattern hair loss.
  • Pumpkin seed oil's key study is a 2014 placebo-controlled trial in 76 Korean men: 400 mg a day of pumpkin seed oil capsules for 24 weeks improved hair count more than placebo.
  • Saw palmetto has several small trials and a systematic review, plus a two-year comparison in which finasteride helped a larger share of men.
  • Typical doses: one standard pumpkin seed oil softgel (most contain 1,000 mg, above the studied 400 mg) and about 320 mg a day of saw palmetto extract.
  • You can take them together; NOW Saw Palmetto Extract 320 mg with Pumpkin Seed Oil combines both in one softgel. Avoid both as hair supplements during pregnancy.

Pumpkin seed oil vs saw palmetto is one of the most common questions from people who want a natural way to support thinning hair. Both are plant-based supplements, both are sold as natural DHT blockers, both are inexpensive, and both often turn up in the same capsule. If you are trying to decide which one to buy, or whether to take both, it helps to see how they really compare.

The encouraging news is that these are two of the better-researched natural options for pattern hair loss. Each has human trials behind it, which is more than most hair supplements can say, and each is generally well tolerated. They are gentler than the prescription drug finasteride, so think of them as natural support for the DHT pathway rather than replacements for proven treatments, and as easy partners for topical minoxidil.

Below, we compare what each supplement is, what the studies found, how they are thought to work, how much to take, capsules versus oil, taking them together, who suits which, what women need to know, side effects and how long to give them. If you are ready to shop, our guide to the best pumpkin seed oil for hair loss ranks softgels and topical oils, and our guide to the best saw palmetto for hair loss ranks extracts on dose and form.

What Pumpkin Seed Oil and Saw Palmetto Are

Pumpkin seed oil and saw palmetto come from very different plants, but they have ended up in the same conversation for the same reason: both have long been used for urinary comfort in men with an enlarged prostate, a gland that is sensitive to DHT, and both are thought to act gently on the enzyme that makes DHT.

Pumpkin seed oil

Pumpkin seed oil is pressed from the seeds of the pumpkin. It is a common food oil, rich in fatty acids and plant sterols, and unrefined versions are dark green with a nutty smell. For hair, it is sold in two forms: softgels taken by mouth, which match the form used in the key trial, and bottles of oil for scalp massage.

Because it is a food oil, pumpkin seed oil has a gentle, well-tolerated reputation. Plain cold-pressed softgels are widely available from established supplement brands at a low monthly cost.

Saw palmetto

Saw palmetto is the berry of a small palm native to the southeastern United States. Extracts of the berry have long been used for prostate symptoms, which is why most bottles are still marketed for prostate health. For hair, the form that matters is a liposterolic extract: an oily concentrate standardized to a high percentage of fatty acids and sterols, usually sold as a softgel.

Saw palmetto is also sold as ground berry powder in capsules. Powder contains far less of the active fatty fraction, so a bigger milligram number on a powder capsule does not mean a stronger product.

The Evidence: Pumpkin Seed Oil vs Saw Palmetto Studies

Pumpkin seed oil's reputation rests mainly on one study. In 2014, Cho and colleagues in Korea published a randomized, double-blind, placebo-controlled trial in 76 men with mild to moderate male pattern hair loss. The men took either 400 mg a day of pumpkin seed oil in capsules or a placebo for 24 weeks. The pumpkin seed oil group had a noticeably larger increase in hair count, and the men rated their own improvement more highly. That is the gold-standard design, which is why the study is taken seriously.

Two details help set expectations. The trial was small and ran in men from one country, and the capsules contained other plant ingredients alongside the pumpkin seed oil, so the result belongs to that formula as a whole. A separate small comparative study in women tested topical pumpkin seed oil against 5% minoxidil foam and reported improvement with the oil, which has made it a popular scalp-massage choice too.

a gentler inhibitor produces a gentler effect

Saw palmetto has a broader but similarly modest evidence base. Several small trials, some using saw palmetto alone and some combining it with other plant compounds, have reported that it can slow hair loss and modestly improve hair counts or appearance in some men, and a systematic review of this research reached a broadly positive conclusion. The studies used different products, doses and ways of measuring results.

The most practical study compared saw palmetto directly with finasteride over two years. Roughly a third of the men taking saw palmetto improved, while finasteride helped a larger share. That fits the mechanism: a gentler inhibitor produces a gentler effect, and it is still encouraging for men who prefer a natural route.

So which has better evidence? Pumpkin seed oil has the cleaner single result, a placebo-controlled trial, while saw palmetto has more studies overall and a head-to-head comparison with finasteride. Neither has the large, long-term trials behind finasteride or minoxidil, and both are best viewed as gentle, low-risk supplements with encouraging research.

Pumpkin Seed OilSaw Palmetto
Key studiesOne placebo-controlled trial in men (2014)Several small trials, a systematic review, a finasteride comparison
Studied dose400 mg a day in capsulesAbout 320 mg a day of lipid extract
Study length24 weeksVaried; the finasteride comparison ran two years
Who was studiedMen with mild to moderate pattern lossMostly men with pattern loss
Main limitsSmall, one country, multi-ingredient capsuleSmall studies, mixed products and doses
Topical researchSmall comparative study in womenSome studies tested topical products
Swipe the table to see more →

How Pumpkin Seed Oil and Saw Palmetto Are Thought to Work

Male and female pattern hair loss are driven largely by dihydrotestosterone, or DHT, which is made from testosterone by an enzyme called 5-alpha reductase. In genetically sensitive follicles, DHT gradually shortens the growth phase and shrinks the follicle, so each new hair grows in finer and shorter. Finasteride works by blocking 5-alpha reductase strongly enough to lower blood DHT substantially.

Both supplements are thought to act on the same enzyme, only far more gently. Saw palmetto's fatty fraction inhibits 5-alpha reductase in laboratory studies. Pumpkin seed oil contains plant sterols and other compounds that, in laboratory and animal research, appear to weakly inhibit the enzyme or otherwise dampen the effects of androgens. Neither is known to meaningfully lower testosterone itself.

they nudge the DHT pathway rather than block it

The best way to describe both is that they nudge the DHT pathway rather than block it. That gentleness is a big part of their appeal, because it comes with a well-tolerated profile, but it also means results build slowly and vary from person to person. It is also why both make the most sense for early pattern thinning, where there are still plenty of miniaturizing hairs that can respond.

Neither supplement addresses shedding caused by stress, illness, childbirth, iron deficiency or thyroid problems, or patchy hair loss. If you are not sure your loss is the pattern type, a dermatologist can usually tell in one visit.

How Much to Take: Dosing Compared

For pumpkin seed oil, the trial used 400 mg a day. Most softgels contain 1,000 mg of oil, so one softgel a day already exceeds the studied dose, and there is no need to take more. Products advertising 3,000 mg or more per serving simply offer bigger numbers. Take one softgel with a meal to reduce the chance of an upset stomach or oily burps.

For saw palmetto, most hair studies used about 320 mg of extract a day, either as one 320 mg softgel or as 160 mg twice daily, usually with food. Higher doses have not been shown to add benefit and mainly raise the chance of stomach upset. The key is the word extract on the label: a 450 mg powder capsule is not stronger than a 320 mg extract softgel.

one softgel a day already exceeds the studied dose

Timing within the day does not matter much for either supplement. Consistency matters far more, so pick a meal you never skip and attach the habit to it.

Pumpkin Seed OilSaw Palmetto
Studied daily dose400 mgAbout 320 mg of extract
Typical product1,000 mg softgel320 mg softgel or two 160 mg softgels
How to take itOne softgel a day with foodOne or two softgels a day with food
Form to buyPlain cold-pressed softgelLipid extract softgel, not berry powder
Swipe the table to see more →

Capsule or Oil? The Best Pumpkin Seed Oil Capsules for Hair Loss

If you are buying pumpkin seed oil for hair loss specifically, softgels are the form to choose, because capsules taken by mouth are what the placebo-controlled trial tested. Topical pumpkin seed oil is a lovely, light scalp conditioner that softens dryness and adds shine, and it has a small study of its own, but the oral form is the one with the stronger evidence for hair. Saw palmetto, by contrast, is almost always taken as an oral extract.

People often search for the best performing pumpkin seed oil supplement in an unbiased study. No study has compared commercial brands head to head, and the trial capsule was a multi-ingredient formula rather than any softgel on the shelf today. So the fairest way to choose is to look for the things the research points to: a plain, cold-pressed pumpkin seed oil, in a softgel, from an established brand, at a dose that covers the studied 400 mg a day.

No study has compared commercial brands head to head

On those criteria, NOW Pumpkin Seed Oil 1000 mg is our best overall pick: plain cold-pressed softgels with no proprietary blend, from an established brand, at the lowest cost per softgel of the branded options we compared. Nature's Way Pumpkin Seed Oil comes in a smaller 60-count starter bottle, and Solaray Pumpkin Seed Oil 1000 mg offers a handy three-month supply. For scalp massage, PURA D'OR Organic Pumpkin Seed Oil is our top topical choice.

Many people enjoy both forms: a daily softgel for the evidence and a weekly pre-wash scalp massage with the oil for comfort and shine. Patch test any topical oil first, and keep amounts small if your scalp is oily.

Softgel (Oral)Topical Oil
Matches the 2014 trial formYesNo
Research for hairPlacebo-controlled trial in menSmall comparative study in women
How it is usedOne softgel a day with foodMassage into scalp, then wash out
Our pickNOW Pumpkin Seed Oil 1000 mgPURA D'OR Organic Pumpkin Seed Oil
Swipe the table to see more →
NOW Supplements Pumpkin Seed Oil 1000 mg, Cold Pressed (200 Softgels)

Our #1 pick for pumpkin seed oil for hair loss

NOW Supplements Pumpkin Seed Oil 1000 mg, Cold Pressed (200 Softgels)

The best value way to try pumpkin seed oil as it was studied: by mouth, plain, from a trusted brand.

Check Price

Can You Take Pumpkin Seed Oil and Saw Palmetto Together?

Yes, you can take pumpkin seed oil and saw palmetto together, and it is one of the most popular pairings in natural hair care. The two are combined so often that some products put them in the same softgel. There is no well-known interaction between them, and both are generally well tolerated on their own.

The simplest way to take both is a single combination softgel. NOW Saw Palmetto Extract 320 mg with Pumpkin Seed Oil, the best overall pick in our saw palmetto guide, delivers the commonly studied 320 mg of saw palmetto extract plus pumpkin seed oil in one softgel, at a low monthly cost. One softgel a day covers both, which makes the habit easy to keep.

it is one of the most popular pairings in natural hair care

If you prefer separate products, for example to know exactly what you are taking or to adjust one without the other, you can pair a saw palmetto extract with a plain pumpkin seed oil softgel. Because both are thought to act on the same enzyme, combining them is best seen as a convenient natural routine rather than a way to double the effect, so there is no need to raise either dose.

Read labels on broader blends. Many hair formulas mix saw palmetto and pumpkin seed oil with biotin and other ingredients, sometimes inside a proprietary blend that hides each dose. Look for products that list every ingredient and amount. If you take finasteride, you usually do not need either supplement, since finasteride already inhibits the same enzyme far more strongly. Minoxidil, which works through a different pathway, pairs well with both.

Pumpkin Seed Oil or Saw Palmetto for Hair Loss: Which Suits You?

Both are good choices, and the right one depends on what matters most to you. Here is how we would decide.

Choose pumpkin seed oil if

You like the idea of a food-based supplement with a placebo-controlled trial behind it, you want the gentlest possible starting point, or you would also enjoy using the oil on your scalp. It is a lovely first step for men with early thinning who want something simple and inexpensive.

Choose saw palmetto if

You want the herbal option with the most hair studies overall, including a direct comparison with finasteride, and you are a man who has considered finasteride and decided against it. A standardized extract at about 320 mg a day is the form to look for.

Choose both if

You want a convenient natural DHT-focused routine in one softgel. The combination product covers the studied saw palmetto dose and adds pumpkin seed oil for little extra cost.

Consider something else if

Your loss is advancing quickly, or you want the strongest possible effect. Topical minoxidil is the over-the-counter treatment FDA-approved for regrowth in men and women, and men can discuss finasteride with a doctor. Either supplement can sit alongside minoxidil.

Pumpkin Seed Oil vs Saw Palmetto for Women

Most research on both supplements has been in men. The pumpkin seed oil capsule trial included only men, although a small study in women looked at the oil applied to the scalp. Some dermatologists use saw palmetto for female pattern hair loss, but evidence in women is still limited.

Pregnancy is the firm exclusion for saw palmetto. Because it acts on male hormones, it could theoretically affect the development of a male fetus, so it should not be taken by women who are pregnant, breastfeeding, trying to conceive or who may become pregnant. Pumpkin seed oil supplements are thought to act on the same pathway, so the same caution applies: do not take them for hair while pregnant, breastfeeding or trying to conceive without talking to your doctor. Neither is for children or teenagers.

Pregnancy is the firm exclusion for saw palmetto.

For women past menopause who are interested in either supplement, a quick conversation with a doctor is the right first step. Topical minoxidil is the FDA-approved option for female pattern thinning, and topical pumpkin seed oil can be a pleasant scalp oil alongside it.

Side Effects and Safety Compared

Pumpkin seed oil is a common food oil and is generally well tolerated. The trial did not report significant side effects. The most likely issues are mild digestive upset, loose stools or burping, which taking it with food usually helps. Anyone allergic to pumpkin seeds should avoid it in both oral and topical form.

Saw palmetto is also generally well tolerated. The most commonly reported side effects are mild stomach upset, nausea, constipation or diarrhea, and headache. A small number of people report reduced libido or other sexual effects, which is not surprising for something that may act on the androgen pathway. There have been rare case reports of bleeding problems, so anyone taking blood thinners or antiplatelet drugs, or with surgery scheduled, should tell their doctor, and anyone with liver disease should check with a physician first.

Saw palmetto is also generally well tolerated.

For both, men should mention the supplement to their doctor before prostate or hormone testing, and anyone taking prescription medication, especially for prostate or hormone-related conditions, should check with a doctor or pharmacist. Buy from an established brand with a clear label, because supplements are not reviewed by the FDA before sale.

Finally, sudden, patchy, painful or rapidly worsening hair loss is worth showing to a dermatologist before you buy any supplement, because those patterns usually have a different cause.

Pumpkin Seed OilSaw Palmetto
Common side effectsMild digestive upset, burpingStomach upset, nausea, headache
Less commonPumpkin seed allergyReduced libido; rare bleeding reports
PregnancyAvoid as a supplementAvoid
Tell your doctor ifYou take prostate or hormone medicationYou take blood thinners or have surgery planned
Swipe the table to see more →

How Long to Try Each One

Give either supplement at least six months. Hair grows in slow cycles, and anything that works on the DHT pathway changes how future hairs grow rather than how today's hairs look. The pumpkin seed oil trial measured results after 24 weeks, and even finasteride usually needs three to six months before changes are visible.

Take clear photos of your hairline, crown and part in the same lighting before you start and every two months after. Slow changes are almost impossible to judge in the mirror. For many people, the realistic goal is stabilization, meaning less loss than you would otherwise have expected, possibly with fuller-looking hair. Stabilization is a meaningful result for a progressive condition.

Stabilization is a meaningful result for a progressive condition.

If you use minoxidil alongside, remember that it can cause a temporary shed in its first couple of months. That is not a reaction to either supplement, so keep going rather than stopping everything at once. At around six months, compare your photos and decide how you want to continue.

Frequently Asked Questions

Is pumpkin seed oil better than saw palmetto for hair loss?

Neither is clearly better. Pumpkin seed oil has one placebo-controlled trial in men, while saw palmetto has more small studies and a head-to-head comparison with finasteride. Both are gentle, well-tolerated options for early pattern hair loss, and many people simply take both in one softgel.

Can you take pumpkin seed oil and saw palmetto together?

Yes. They are commonly combined, and there is no well-known interaction between them. NOW Saw Palmetto Extract 320 mg with Pumpkin Seed Oil puts both in one daily softgel. There is no need to raise either dose when you combine them.

What is the best pumpkin seed oil capsule for hair loss?

NOW Pumpkin Seed Oil 1000 mg is our best overall pick: plain, cold-pressed softgels from an established brand at a low cost per softgel. One softgel a day already covers the 400 mg used in the 2014 trial.

Which pumpkin seed oil performed best in an unbiased study?

No independent study has compared pumpkin seed oil brands. The 2014 trial used a multi-ingredient capsule supplied for the study rather than a product sold today. The best approach is a plain, cold-pressed softgel from an established brand at a dose that covers 400 mg a day.

How much saw palmetto and pumpkin seed oil should I take?

Most saw palmetto hair studies used about 320 mg of extract a day, and the pumpkin seed oil trial used 400 mg a day. One 320 mg saw palmetto softgel and one standard 1,000 mg pumpkin seed oil softgel, or a single combination softgel, taken with food, is plenty.

Can I take pumpkin seed oil or saw palmetto with minoxidil?

Yes. Minoxidil works through a different pathway, supporting the growth phase of the follicle, so it pairs well with either supplement or both. Expect a possible temporary shed in the first couple of months of minoxidil, which is not a reaction to the supplement.

Should I take either one if I already use finasteride?

Usually not. Finasteride already inhibits the same enzyme far more strongly, so the supplements add little. If you want to do more, minoxidil or ketoconazole shampoo are the natural additions to discuss with your doctor.

Do pumpkin seed oil or saw palmetto lower testosterone?

Neither has been shown to meaningfully lower testosterone. Both are thought to act on the enzyme that converts testosterone into DHT, not on testosterone production. If you notice changes in libido or mood, stop and talk to your doctor.

The Bottom Line

Pumpkin seed oil and saw palmetto are two of the best-researched natural supplements for early pattern hair loss, and the choice between them is less important than taking one consistently. Choose pumpkin seed oil for a gentle, food-based softgel with a placebo-controlled trial, choose saw palmetto for the herbal option with the most studies, or take both in one combination softgel. Pair either with minoxidil, avoid both in pregnancy, and judge results with photos at six months.